1. The Exclusive Constitutional Mechanism: Article 239(4)
In constitutional jurisprudence, when the supreme law of the land prescribes a specific, mandatory procedure for performing a sovereign act, that act can only be performed in that exact manner, and every other method is impliedly prohibited (expressio unius est exclusio alterius).
• Constitutional Entrenchment of Provincial Territory (Article 1): Article 1(2)(a) of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973, explicitly defines the territories of the Federation by enumerating the four Provinces—specifically naming Sindh. Because the territorial existence of Sindh is written directly into the text of Article 1, any alteration of its boundaries requires a formal Constitutional Amendment.
• The Dual Super-Majority Requirement (Article 239(4)): Part XI of the Constitution governs the amendment of the Constitution. While ordinary constitutional amendments require a two-thirds majority of the total membership of both Houses of Parliament (National Assembly and Senate) under Article 239(1)–(3), Article 239(4) erects an extraordinary, heightened barrier specifically for provincial boundaries:
"A Bill to amend the Constitution which would have the effect of altering the limits of a Province shall not be presented to the President for assent unless it has been passed by the Provincial Assembly of that Province by the votes of not less than two-thirds of its total membership."
• Legislative Sovereignty vs. Direct Plebiscite: Pakistan operates as a representative parliamentary federation, not a direct plebiscitary democracy. The Constitution vests the constituent power to consent to boundary changes exclusively in the elected Provincial Assembly of Sindh acting through a two-thirds super-majority vote. Even if a referendum were somehow conducted and returned a majority vote in favor of altering borders, it would possess zero constitutional validity. Without a formal Constitutional Amendment Bill passed by two-thirds of the National Assembly, two-thirds of the Senate, and two-thirds of the total membership of the Provincial Assembly of Sindh, the territorial limits of Sindh under Article 1 remain legally unaltered.
2. Constitutional Scope and Limitations of a Referendum: Article 48(6)
The sole provision in the 1973 Constitution that authorizes a referendum is Article 48(6) (as substituted by the Eighteenth Constitutional Amendment in 2010). A textual and structural reading of Article 48(6) demonstrates why it cannot be invoked to alter provincial boundaries:
• Textual Preconditions: Under Article 48(6), if at any time the Prime Minister considers it necessary to hold a referendum on "any matter of national importance," the Prime Minister may refer the matter to a joint sitting of the Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament). Only if the joint sitting approves the reference by a majority vote can the matter be referred to a referendum in the form of a question capable of being answered either by "Yes" or "No."
• Distinction Between Policy Consultation and Constituent Power: A referendum under Article 48(6) is a consultative or policy-legitimizing mechanism—it is not a constituent power capable of amending the Constitution. In constitutional law, Article 48(6) (located in Part III, Chapter 1, governing the Executive/President) cannot override or bypass Article 239(4) (located in Part XI, exclusively governing Constitutional Amendments). Allowing an executive-initiated referendum under Article 48(6) to alter provincial boundaries would render Article 239(4) completely redundant—violating the settled rule of constitutional interpretation that no provision of the Constitution can be interpreted in a manner that destroys or neutralizes another provision.
• Prohibition of Sub-National or Localized Referendums: Article 48(6) contemplates only a nationwide referendum of all registered voters of Pakistan on a matter of national importance. There is no provision anywhere in the Constitution permitting a sub-national, regional, provincial, or municipal referendum (for instance, polling only the residents of a single city or division such as Karachi or Hyderabad) to secede from an existing province.
3. Absence of Statutory Authority and the Role of the Election Commission
Under Article 218(3) and Article 219 of the Constitution, the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) is a constitutional body bound strictly by the four corners of the Constitution and statutes enacted by Parliament:
• No Statutory Mandate in the Elections Act, 2017: The Elections Act, 2017 (which consolidated and repealed previous election laws, including the Referendum Act, 1977) contains no mechanism, procedure, or legal authority for holding a territorial or boundary-alteration referendum.
• Ultra Vires Executive Action: Neither the Federal Government (under Article 97) nor the Provincial Government (under Article 137) possesses executive authority to direct the ECP to hold a referendum on provincial boundaries. Furthermore, Article 89 (President's Ordinance-making power) and Article 128 (Governor's Ordinance-making power) cannot be used to authorize a territorial referendum, as Ordinance-making power is co-extensive with ordinary legislative power and cannot encroach upon the constituent domain of Article 239(4).
4. Jurisprudential Safeguards: Federalism as a Salient Feature
The Superior Judiciary of Pakistan has consistently affirmed that Federalism and Provincial Autonomy are foundational pillars (salient features) of the 1973 Constitution:
• Inviolability of Constitutional Procedure: In landmark constitutional jurisprudence—including Mahmood Khan Achakzai v. Federation of Pakistan (PLD 1997 SC 426), Wukala Mahaz Barai Tahafuz Dastoor v. Federation of Pakistan (PLD 1998 SC 1263), and District Bar Association, Rawalpindi v. Federation of Pakistan (PLD 2015 SC 401)—the Supreme Court of Pakistan affirmed that federalism is one of the defining salient features of the 1973 Constitution, and that the procedural mandates of Article 239 are mandatory and strictly binding.
• Judicial Review and Injunctive Relief: Any executive notification, parliamentary resolution, or ordinance seeking to hold a referendum to alter the territorial limits of Sindh would be immediately vulnerable to invalidation under:
◦ Article 184(1) of the Constitution: Original and exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court in disputes between the Federal Government and the Government of Sindh.
◦ Article 184(3) of the Constitution: Enforcement of fundamental rights involving questions of public importance.
◦ Article 199 of the Constitution: Writ jurisdiction of the High Court of Sindh to declare any unauthorized administrative or electoral step coram non judice and without lawful authority.
5. Comparative Matrix of Legal Mechanisms
| Mechanism / Instrument | Legal Authority | Alteration Validity | Constitutional Reasoning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Constitutional Amendment Bill | Article 239(4) & Article 1(2) | Valid (Sole Lawful Method) | Requires 2/3 majority of National Assembly, 2/3 of Senate, AND 2/3 of total membership of Sindh Provincial Assembly. |
| National Referendum | Article 48(6) | Invalid | Applies only to general policy matters of national importance approved by a joint sitting of Parliament; cannot amend Article 1 or bypass Article 239(4). |
| Provincial or Local Referendum | None exists | Invalid / Unconstitutional | Completely unknown to Pakistani constitutional and statutory law; ECP has zero jurisdiction to conduct localized plebiscites. |
| Presidential Ordinance / Executive Order | Articles 89 & 97 | Invalid / Void ab initio | Executive authority and Ordinances cannot amend the Constitution or override the constituent veto of the Sindh Assembly. |
6. Conclusion
Under the prevailing constitutional order of Pakistan, the territorial integrity of Sindh is protected by an unyielding dual-lock mechanism: national parliamentary consensus paired with the explicit super-majority consent of the Provincial Assembly of Sindh. Because the Constitution neither recognizes direct plebiscitary boundary-making nor permits Article 48(6) to substitute for Article 239(4), the territorial limits of Sindh cannot legally be altered through a referendum under any circumstances.
Author: Asif Ali Abbasi







Reader Discussion (0)
MODERATED · NO LINKS OR SPAMLoading reader comments...